Based on the beloved 1953 Doris Day classic, Calamity Jane has been adored by audiences ever since. Having had many stage adaptations over the years, it has been some time since the classic graced the stage. The wait is over, with nostalgia being well and truly restored, as Calamity Jane whip-cracks its way across the UK.
Like many golden age musicals, the plot itself is simple. However, with this comes bucket loads of charm, and fans of the film won’t be disappointed. However, it does feel like it gets there too quickly at times. The relationships between characters often feel underdeveloped, making it hard to have a deeper connection with the story itself. However, the performances themselves more than make up for this.
Carrie Hope Fletcher is sublime as Calamity Jane, playing the role with sass and likability in equal abundance. She proves her status as one of our country’s finest leading ladies with her commanding stage presence and spine-tingling vocals. Vinny Coyle is equally fantastic as Wild Bill Hickok, stealing the show completely with his rendition of ‘Higher Than a Hawk’ for the act two opener. Whilst their performances here are superb, their relationship could have benefited from more development through the script itself.
The standout element of this production is the cast. They work tirelessly together to deliver laugh-out-loud moments throughout the show. It’s impossible not to have a great time watching Calamity Jane. What’s refreshing, particularly for a touring production, is that the cast is mostly made up of actor-musicians. Although their talent is undeniable, it doesn’t entirely work as a concept. With many of the band members having limited roles, it felt at times like they were just a band on stage rather than an integral part of the show. The music lacked a fullness, leaving key moments without the emotional punch they deserved through the beloved score.
Despite its shortcomings, Calamity Jane is brimming with heart and humour. With lively choreography against rustic staging, it gives a real dose of nostalgia for long-time fans. That said, it may be time for a fresh reimagining to make it exciting for a new generation of theatre fans.
Note: My ticket was gifted. Irrespective of whether a ticket is gifted or bought, I always ensure that my reviews are fair and based on my honest opinion alone.