Miracle on 34th Street is one of those cherished Christmas classics that holds a special place in many people's hearts. Having fond memories of the 1994 film starring Richard Attenborough and Mara Wilson, I was excited to see how it would translate on stage. With the original 1947 film being a multi-Academy Award winner, the question was: can a musical version elevate to something even more magical?
We meet Susan, a young girl who doesn’t believe in Santa Claus, with her mum’s skepticism having caught on. 10-year-old Karis Musongole, known for her role as young Elphaba in the recent Wicked blockbuster, shines as Susan. She commands your attention entirely as she challenges her belief, leading the talented cast with ease. Karis certainly has a very bright future ahead of her.
While the production features a sprinkling of good songs, they are sadly few and far between. The highlight musically, instead, comes from the impressive four-piece band. They work tirelessly to try to infuse the magic that is otherwise sadly missing from the show.
The set design offers a promising start, with an arch of toys framing the stage. However, any hope of a more visually exciting show is dashed, with this never being built on fully. At several points throughout, a black curtain comes down as scenes are played out without sets. Whilst presumably giving stagehands more opportunity to prepare for the following scene, it comes off as feeling cheap; missing the opportunity to fully visualise any grandeur of the iconic Macy’s store in which much of the show is set.
Pacing is perhaps the production’s most significant downfall. Clocking in at almost three hours on press night, it is quite simply too long for a family show. The first act, in particular, feels excessively long at 90 minutes and could easily be streamlined. This adaptation incorporates back-and-forth between the UK and New York City, adding little to the narrative whilst detracting from the storytelling. A more streamlined plot, more in line with the films on which it is based, would have made for a more engaging experience.
Despite its talented cast, this musical adaptation struggles to capture the magic that made Miracle on 34th Street so beloved on film. Miracle on 34th Street plays at HOME in Manchester until Tuesday 31 December 2024.
Note: My ticket was gifted. Irrespective of whether a ticket is gifted or bought, I always ensure that my reviews are fair and based on my honest opinion alone.